Reverse Mortgage - Forward Thinking

Reverse mortgage lenders, the elder law bar and the public did not get off on the right foot when reverse mortgages became generally available. There were many confusing features to the initial loans and the government and banks did little to help borrowers understand their transactions. Reverse mortgages became known as the estate planning tool of last resort for truly financially needy elders. The elder law bar was hesitant to recommend reverse mortgages, estate planning lawyers put their heads in the sand and real estate lawyers, at least many of the real estate lawyers in Massachusetts that my law firm deals with, were completely in the dark on the workings and benefits of reverse mortgages. So what has changed? In a word, education.

The reverse mortgage industry made it their mission to educate the market place, not only consumers but also lenders about the powerful benefits of reverse mortgages. As with any schooling it takes time. Sometimes you take the wrong class or get a bad professor, but if you stick to it great things can happen. That is the case with reverse mortgages. Lawyers, geriatric care managers, lenders, borrowers and other interested parties are now coming to see the place for reverse mortgages in elder law planning. To me the key benefit of reverse mortgages is their ability to create peace of mind through financial independence. So there has been education; why else have reverse mortgages suddenly emerged as a viable planning tool for older estate planning clients? Life is expensive, particularly in states like Massachusetts where we seldom see a purchase and sale agreement for less than $400,000. As the population ages and the housing market remains strong (yes, it is still very strong by historical measures - in the Boston area real estate is still considerably overpriced when taking all other aspects of the cost of living into account,) elders have more month than they have monthly income.

Most reverse mortgages are used to convert home equity into a replacement for insufficient income. When you look deeper the net effect of reverse mortgages is that more elders can stay in their own homes longer, more elders are able to afford home care services and more elders have the sense of financial freedom that only comes from knowing that there is money in the bank. What's not to love about reverse mortgages? Well, real estate brokers in Massachusetts don't like reverse mortgages - they slow down the transaction pace and change the traditional marketing cycle of listing elders' homes when they can no longer afford them. The assisted living industry doesn't like reverse mortgages. How could they? They depend on elders giving up their old homes in return for 3 squares and a cot at their local "Happy Garden Loving Home for Golden Years on Smiling Hill Assisted Living and Schmaltz Factory." I found this primer on reverse mortgages useful, not only for my elder law colleagues that follow the blog, but also for the general public that wants to more about the basic mechanics of reverse mortgages. Just remember that reverse mortgage laws can vary by state and also it is a good idea to consult an elder law lawyer in Massachusetts or your state before proceeding with a reverse mortgage or any estate plan or real estate transaction.

Reverse Mortgage Loans For many seniors the equity in their home is their largest single asset, yet it is unavailable to use unless they use a conventional home-equity loan. But a conventional loan really doesn't free up the equity because the money has to be paid back with interest. A reverse mortgage is a risk-free way of tapping into home equity without creating monthly payments and without requiring the money to be paid back during a person's lifetime. Instead of making payments the cash flow is reversed and the senior receives payments from the bank. Thus the title "reverse mortgage". Many seniors are finding they can use a reverse mortgage to pay off an existing conventional mortgage, to create money for a down payment for a second home or to pay off debt. Popularity is skyrocketing. Over the last five years the number of reverse mortgages nationwide has tripled. The uses of this untapped wealth are only limited by a person's imagination. For those seniors who earn low incomes but own a home, a reverse mortgage can allow them to remain in the home by creating extra income. It can also allow for remodeling or repairs and when the time comes to sell, the investment in the home can make it more valuable. False Beliefs about Reverse Mortgages "The lender could take my house." The homeowner retains full ownership. The Reverse Mortgage is just like any other mortgage; you own the title and the bank holds a lien. You can pay it off anytime you like. "I can be thrown out of my own home." Homeowners can stay in the home as long as they live, with no payment requirement. "I could end up owing more than my house is worth." The homeowner can never owe more than the value of the home at the time the loan is due. "My heirs will be against it." Experience demonstrates heirs are in favor of Reverse Mortgages.

Virtually anyone can qualify. You must be at least 62, own and live in, as a primary residence, a home [1-4 family residence, condominium, co-op, permanent mobile home, or manufactured home] in order to qualify for a reverse mortgage. There are no income, asset or credit requirements. It is the easiest loan to qualify for. A reverse mortgage is similar to a conventional mortgage. As an example: The bank does not own the home but owns a lien on the property just as with any other mortgage You continue to hold title to the property as with any other mortgage The bank has no recourse to demand payment from any family member if there is not enough equity to cover paying off the loan There is no penalty to pay off the mortgage early When the loan becomes due, you can refinance and keep the house. The proceeds from a reverse mortgage are tax-free and can be used for any legal purpose you wish: daily living expenses home repairs and improvements medical bills and prescription drugs pay-off of existing debts education, travel long-term care and/or long-term care insurance financial and estate tax plans gifts and trusts to purchase life insurance or any other needs you may have. The amount of reverse mortgage benefit for which you may qualify, will depend on your age at the time you apply for the loan, the reverse mortgage program you choose, the value of your home, current interest rates, and for some products, where you live. As a general rule, the older you are and the greater your equity, the larger the reverse mortgage benefit will be (up to certain limits, in some cases). The reverse mortgage must pay off any outstanding liens against your property before you can withdraw additional funds. The loan is not due and payable until the borrower no longer occupies the home as a principal residence (i.e. the borrower sells, moves out permanently or passes away). At that time, the balance of borrowed funds is due and payable, all additional equity in the property belongs to the owners or their beneficiaries. If the heirs want to keep the home with the additional equity, they can refinance with a conventional loan. There are three reverse mortgage loan products available, the FHA - HECM (Home Equity Conversion Mortgage), Fannie Mae - HomeKeeper®, and the Cash Account programs. Over 90% of all reverse mortgages are HECM contracts. The costs associated with getting a reverse mortgage are similar to those with a conventional mortgage, such as the origination fee, appraisal and inspection fees, title policy, mortgage insurance and other normal closing costs. With a reverse mortgage, all of these costs will be financed as part of the mortgage prior to your withdrawal of additional funds. You must participate in an independent Credit Counseling session with an FHA-approved counselor early in the application process for a reverse mortgage. The counselor's job is to educate you about all of your mortgage options. This counseling session is at no cost to the borrower and can be done in person or, more typically, over the telephone. After completing this counseling, you will receive a Counseling Certificate in the mail which must be included as part of the reverse mortgage application. You can choose 3 options to receive the money from a reverse mortgage: 1) all at once (lump sum); 2) fixed monthly payments (for up to life); 3) a line of credit; or a combination of a line of credit and monthly payments. The most popular option, chosen by more than 60 percent of borrowers, is the line of credit, which allows you to draw on the loan proceeds at any time. The line of credit also earns interest which in essence is allowing the equity in the home to grow.

For example $120,000 in a line of credit earning 5% would be worth almost 200,$000 10 years from now. Keeping money in a reverse mortgage line of credit in most states will not count as an asset for Medicaid eligibility as this would be considered a loan and not a resource for Medicaid spend down. In other words, keeping the money in the line of credit will not disqualify you from becoming Medicaid eligible. However, transferring the money to an investment or to a bank account would represent an asset and would trigger a spend down requirement and delay eligibility. Please note however that distinguishing between what portion of reverse mortgage proceeds might be counted as a loan and what portion as an asset is not a simple black and white decision. It is best to get an opinion from an elder attorney in your state.

If a senior homeowner chooses to repay any portion of the interest accruing against his borrowed funds, the payment of this interest may be deductible (just as any mortgage interest may be). A reverse mortgage loan will be available to a senior homeowner to draw upon for as long as that person lives in the home. And, in some cases, the lender increases the total amount of the line of credit over time (unlike a traditional Home Equity Line where the credit limit is established at origination). If a senior homeowner stays in the property until he or she dies, his or her estate valuation will be reduced by the amount of the debt. At the death of the last borrower or the sale of the home, the loan is repaid from equity in the home. Any remaining equity (which is often the case) goes to the heirs. Almost all reverse mortgages are the HECM loan which is guaranteed by FHA mortgage insurance. If there is not enough equity to cover the loan, the insurance satisfies the loan by paying the deficit. With a HECM loan, the bank will never come after the heirs to satisfy the mortgage obligation. Good resources for reverse mortgage information are AARP, the Ed Barrett at Your Home for Life mortgage company (781-329-6644) and the National Reverse Mortgage Lenders Association.

Using Reverse Mortgages in Complex Estate Planning - What Elder Homeowners Need to Know

Reverse mortgages are not just for poor people anymore. I am tired of hearing about reverse mortgages - in the past six months it's as if someone flipped a switch to turn up the noise, not necessarily the quality, of the messaging to elders about reverse mortgages.  

In my practice as an estate planner in Massachusetts I am often called upon to "get creative" on behalf of clients. As one of only a few true legal experts in the reverse mortgage industry, my creativity often opens the discussion with clients about complex uses of reverse mortgages in estate planning.

 I have developed several methods to leverage the equity value of a client's house to enhance either the economic benefit or overall personal security of clients. To explain the concepts in shorthand, Gosselin Law claims a servicemark on the shorthand names of many of our approaches. Here are examples of somewhat magical things that can be done with reverse mortgages as an estate planning tool.

GOLDEN TRIANGLE(sm). The Golden Triangle demonstrates to elders looking to plan for long term care how to use the reverse mortgage as a tool for closing the five year gap provided under the new Medicaid laws. It is a triangle as there is an estate plan, a long term care plan and a reverse mortgage plan coming together to provide for both current and future long term care needs. Here's how it works:

Mary, a 77 year old widow in Boston, has lived in her own home for over 40 years. This is the house that sheltered her family, where her dear husband passed and where she intends to stay until the very end. Although Mary has a good pension from the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Social Security and adequate short term savings,  Mary is concerned that if she needed long term medical care that she could not afford to remain in her home or pay for a nursing home. Mary also wants to provide as much for her family upon her death as possible; after all she and her husband both worked hard to be able to leave something for their three children.

Mary's good health and family history of longevity helps indicate that Mary will likely grow to be very old. Her home is valued at $450,000 in today's real estate market. Based on her age, current interest rates and the property's values, Mary's HECM line of credit will be about $280,000 at closing. Mary qualifies for long term care insurance, but she feels that the $5,000 annual premium, although vitally important to her ability to remain in her home, is too much to pay on her fixed income. As many elder law lawyer advised her to  transfer the house to avoid exposure to a Medicaid lien - but every technique available requires a 5 year waiting period before she would be elegible for Medicaid.  At 77, Mary could live 15, 20 years or even longer - so even with her fixed income and ongoing inflation, she will no longer be able to afford to stay in her home in the not so distant future.

By securing a HECM reverse mortgage line of credit or similar reverse mortgage product, Mary will enable herself to have access to both a current and ready pool of cash, but also an appreciating line of credit that will be available to her for the rest of her life. Using a $5,000 per year draw, Mary will be able to buy the "Cadillac" of long term care insurance (including extensive home care benefits and high benefit limits) which will also serve to exempt her house from Medicaid liens immediately, without waiting for five years. At the same time, Mary's estate planning will have time to season. After five years, Mary will have had the peace of mind in the form of long term care insurance, lifetime financial security, and in her ever increasing available HECM cash and a now permanent estate plan to carry out her wishes. A Golden Triangle, indeed.

An interesting variation on the reverse mortgage that could work well in the Golden Triangle is the "Retirement Mortgage" from Virgin Money. Essentially a child acts as the reverse mortgage lender, documents the transaction as a loan to ensure that he or she is repaid before any other siblings at the time of the elder's death. I am a big proponent of Virgin Money (full disclosure is that I am working with Virgin Money in developing new and exciting products for the US market), on the principle that families should be helping each other first before turning to often high cost products from the financial services community. 

SNOWBIRD(sm). In the Snowbird(sm) we show reverse mortgage companies how to prospect with sunbelt real estate agents to facilitate the purchase of properties with reverse mortgages, primary residences can be obtained with a reverse mortgage purchase money mortgage, and secondary residence by using a reverse mortgage leveraged primary residence in Massachusetts as collateral for the real estate purchase. Similarly, we show elder homeowners how to conserve cash by using reverse mortgages as purchase money mortgages. Here's an example:

Bob and Cathy, 70 and 68 respectively, haved lived in their lovely 4 bedroom home in Newton for over 30 years. Now retired, Bob and Cathy enjoy playing golf, sailing and visiting with their two children and their families (who both live in the Greater Boston area). As much as they enjoy the New England seasons, they enjoy spending the Winter and long weekends in Florida. They have made many new friends and enjoy the Florida lifestyle, especially in the Clearwater Beach area.

Financially, Bob and Cathy have not fared too well. Bob worked for Polaroid for over 30 years, but because of its collapse, his pension benefits and stock savings (all in Polaroid stock) are meager at best. Bob continues to work part time at The Country Club in Brookline, which also gets him some free time on the greens. Cathy never worked outside the home, but has been doing quite well organizing Ebay sales for her friends and neighbors looking to downsize their homes. The thought of doing this at this point in her life brings Cathy to tears, but she and Bob agree that they would enjoy having a place in Florida during their healthy retirement years.

Based on Bob and Cathy's ages, current interest rates and the $800,000 value of their Newton home, they could borrow approximately $425,000 in reverse mortgage cash. They could draw it all at the closing or take some in a lump sum and leave rest to be available for future withdrawals. Bob and Cathy would very much like to purchase a $200,000 condominium in Clearwater Beach condominiums, not far from their favorite public golf course.

By taking out a reverse mortgage as above, Bob and Cathy will have the best of all worlds. They will have the cash they need to buy the Florida condominium outright (and enjoy its appreciation throughout their retirement), a financial cushion in the form of the remaining credit line on their Newton home, and most importantly, will be able to keep and enjoy their home. Of course, interest will acrrue on their borrowings, but between the expected appreciation of the Florida property and the value they place on the two-home lifestyle, Bob and Cathy will have it all in retirement thanks to the Snowbird.

ROBINHOOD(sm). The Robinhood(sm) guides more sophisticated and larger property value elders on the use of asset leverage by using other financial products, especially second to die life insurance. In simple terms, the reverse mortgage is used to pay premiums and the actuarial analysis results in a positive arbitrage for the reverse mortgage borrower. Here's a simple example to ilustrate the idea:

Mike and Sheila enjoy financial security by anyone's measure. Mike, recently turned 65, and Sheila, 66, just sold their successful software company to a larger competitor - realizing over $10 million in restricted stock in the buyer from the sale. Adding that to their $2 million primary residence in Brookline, $3 million Nantucket home and $5 million in other savings, mainly in qualified retirement plans, Mike and Sheila will pass a large estate on to their five children. Or, will they only fill the coffers of the US Treasury? Based on a $20 million estate, Mike and Sheila's estate planning attorney showed them a potential estate tax of over $6 million if they were to die this year.

If we were their attorneys, we would suggest setting up an irrevocable life insurance trust (ILIT) to hold a survivorship (second to die) life insurance policy. As wealthy as they may seem, Mike and Sheila lack sufficient liquidity to commit to a relatively large insurance premium, although the arbitrage on the numbers clearly show the economic benefit of establishing such an estate plan while they are young and healthy. The solution? A reverse mortgage, either on a line of credit basis where premiums are paid annually or a lump sum cash account where Mike and Sheila can purchase their life insurance (through the ILIT) with a single premium.

By using the reverse mortgage to pay the life insurance premium, Mike and Sheila will get the liquidity they need without running afoul of income tax rules or using restricted or otherwise inaccessible assets to pay for the needed life insurance. Upon the second of Mike and Sheila's death, the overall estate will be liquidated and the reverse mortgage paid in full with part of the cash proceeds of the life insurance policy, the balance to be used for paying estate taxes or direct bequests to their family. Based on a sophisticated side-by-side analysis of their reverse mortgage projections and life insurance guarantees, Mike and Sheila can make an educated arbitrage decision without significant risk of economic loss.

We are not licensed to provide insurance or loan products and any decision to proceed with any of these advanced reverse mortgage plans requires you to work with your trusted advisors. But, Gosselin Law can help our clients evaluate various complex uses of insurance and mortgage tools, as well as suggest reliable sales organizations

Gosselin Law is one of the only elder law firms in the country with a reverse mortgage specialty practice. We can assist homeowners in the states where we are licensed or associated with local counsel with the planning of reverse mortgages, coordination of federal benefits with reverse mortgage loan proceeds and gerneral asset protection and estate planning.

Infinite Monkey Theorem of Prime Boston Real Estate

I went to the Boston Red Sox this past Saturday with my 7 year old. I measure the success of a trip to the Red Sox with one of my sons by a complicated calculus of the number of innings we actually watch, the number of innings spent in the restroom, the cost of souvenirs and the number of different snacks consumed. Well, this game was a winner on all counts.

It started as we settled into our comfortable first base line seats with our Fenway Franks and peanuts still in the shell. A father and son of about the same age as my son and myself desperately came up to us and asked if we would switch seats with them. You see, the little boy, in his little league Red Sox uniform and wearing his Franklin/Butch Hobson glove - must have been dad's glove, was focused on catching a foul ball. His dad, through one connection or another had managed to get the 'seats of a lifetime' directly behind home plate. These seats offered an amazing view of every pitch and a closeness to the players that verges on creepy. But, because of some Massachusetts lawyer in 1912, there's a net behind home plate so the well-heeled fans don't lose any teeth. Seeing that I could both score great seats and make this little boy's day (that would be the little boy in ME), we moved down to Section 47.

We did see what we had expected from this very special little piece of prime Boston real estate - not to mention hearing the sounds of the game like never before. A Curt Shilling fast ball smacking Varitek's glove brings resounding joy to the true believers. Because of the netting surrounding our little area, it can feel a little like a cage with us chimpanzees looking out at the rest of the fans and the field. After $100 a ticket for the seat, probably $50 a head in snacks and drinks and as much to park - do you think that some of the best major league ball players in the world would provide the best entertainment to those lucky chimpanzees in the home plate cage? Nope. Pro baseball was a distant second to the chimpanzees' favorite sport - watching people relate to foul balls. Not a stray ball was hit that didn't lead the crowd to a strong emotional response. OOOHHHH!!! She really got 'beaned' by that one! Beer Bath Row 15!! One hander! Cute kid with glove run down by fat drunk guy! Fumble by the rich guy with the field seat he doesn't deserve the ball. Holy Bleachers Batman! He's going to fall into left field! And on, and on, and on. I have never seen such a degree of mass human entertainment since those expert lawyers in the OJ Case made a mockery of the American legal system and embarrassed lawyers wholesale across the country. And so it went for the entire game (which was as good as a baseball game gets by the way) - the chimpanzees hooped and hollered about every last ball.

Don't forget the grounded fouls. "Give the ball to the kid." The all powerful ball boy granted $6 rawhide wishes on deserving fans throughout the game. Even Manny Ramirez and David Ortiz went out of their ways to toss balls into the stands - they know how the chimpanzees love their bananas! We could all save a lot of money and just have a pitcher and a batter on the field (that should keep us under the payroll cap) hitting balls into the stands to see who loses a tooth, gets a black eye or makes the people 25 feet below him smell like a brewery. It might lower the cost of this Boston real estate, but then again with all the lawyers in Boston, they might make them put up a net around the whole crowd - even people in the cheap real estate can then be chimpanzees too!